Facebook Causes Poor Grades … Really?!

The TimesOnline reports that

FACEBOOK users may feel socially successful in cyberspace but they are more likely to perform poorly in exams, according to new research into the academic impact of the social networking website.

I know Facebook can cause nasty viruses that can make you lose files and that can CAUSE bad grades.  But I wondered, how did this study draw a correlation between FACEBOOK time and bad grades.  And then … I wondered if my blogging career would have a similar result.  Will my Straight A average plummet the more I blog?  Horrorifying thought!!

The Canadian Press reports:

Study co-author Aryn Karpinski, a doctoral student and graduate teaching associate at Ohio State University, said the researchers wanted to look at demographic differences of student Facebook users and non-users and to investigate their typical profiles.

Karpinski and Adam Duberstein of Ohio Dominican University are presenting their research Thursday in San Diego at the annual meeting of the American Education Research Foundation.

The researchers surveyed 219 students at Ohio State - 102 undergraduates and 117 graduates - in the summer and fall quarters of 2008. Of that total, 148 said they had Facebook accounts.Study co-author Aryn Karpinski, a doctoral student and graduate teaching associate at Ohio State University, said the researchers wanted to look at demographic differences of student Facebook users and non-users and to investigate their typical profiles.
Karpinski and Adam Duberstein of Ohio Dominican University are presenting their research Thursday in San Diego at the annual meeting of the American Education Research Foundation.

The researchers surveyed 219 students at Ohio State - 102 undergraduates and 117 graduates - in the summer and fall quarters of 2008. Of that total, 148 said they had Facebook accounts.

The award for most misleading article goes to the TimesOnline.  Did they really draw the conclusion that FACEBOOK is the cause of a B average vs. an A average for students? Sure, based on the study, their is a correlation for these students. But let’s face it, the study is not conclusive in any way.

  1. The population studied was too small
  2. There are no control variables (is the control group taking harder classes)
  3. The time span is too small

I think the TimesOnline gets an “F” for trying to mislead readers.  Just proves that studies can be manipulated to say anything the media wants.  Keep questioning, and don’t believe everything you read!

4 Comments

  1. Sarah Ebner says:

    Hi
    Not trying to mislead - and we did include the quote from the researcher that Facebook is unlikely to be the only reason why the grades were lower. I think there may well be a correlation, but you might disagree!
    Thanks for reading School Gate
    PS I love the Breakfast Club - it’s probably my favourite high school film (well, with Election). I’ve done some posts on movies on the blog, best teachers/worst teachers in films etc. I think you might like them….
    (let me know if you want to know more, or maybe look at the library links on the main page, as I don’t want to feel like a spammer!)

  2. Chloe Mays says:

    Hi Sarah,

    Thanks for the note. I will check out the links.

    Chloe

  3. Adam says:

    Hi Chloe,

    Thank you so much for referencing our study! You are indeed correct to note that correlation is not causation. I’m impressed that you are still in high school–keep writing–you definitely have a bright future ahead of you!

    I am hoping that future research will look at the benefits that Facebook could offer to students as an educational tool. I know mine will head in that direction.

    Thanks again for sharing your blog with us readers!

    Peace,
    Adam

  4. Chloe Mays says:

    Thanks for reading my blog. Please keep me posted on future studies.

Leave a Reply